6:54 | 21/04/2012 | 60

East Sea has stronger legitimacy than Sea of Japan

This proves that the name east sea dates back more than 2,000 years, 1,700 years before the first appearance of the name sea of japan in "mappamondo", a publication.

East Sea has stronger legitimacy than Sea of Japan

College students take part in a campaign at Gwanghwamun Square in central Seoul early this month to promote the East Sea ahead of the International Hydrographic Organization’s general meeting in Monaco April 23-27. The organization will determine how to describe the body of water between the Korean Peninsula and Japan in the world’s most creditable guideline for maps./ Korea Times file

Long-festering naming controversy to be debated in IHO meeting next week

By Park Chang-seok

“Until the East Sea’s waves are dry, Mt. Baekdu are worn away, as God protects our land, our Korea lasts forever, manse!…” This is part of the Korean national anthem “Aegukka”.

The “East Sea” (“Donghae” in Korean) is mentioned in the first line of “Aegukka”, literally meaning an ode to Koreans’ patriotism. The East Sea is not just a body of water – it is the history of Korea, the soul of Koreans. So, it’s not up for geographical appellation debate.

The East Sea, or the “Sea of Japan?” What to call the body of water bordered by Korea, Japan and Russia remains controversial. The Republic of Korea insists on the East Sea, while Japan claims it’s the Sea of Japan.

Koreans have called the waters the East Sea for about 2,000 years, as seen in their national anthem, according to historical documents. The Sea of Japan has been in use since the International Hydrographic Organization (IHO), a body in charge of naming the oceans and seas, used the name in its first edition of “Limits of Oceans and Seas” in 1929. The long-festering controversy will again be debated in an IHO general meeting in Monaco from April 23 to 27.

East Sea has stronger legitimacy than Sea of Japan

In general, geographical names reflect the history, culture, lifestyle and philosophy of the people who use them. The name East Sea is no exception. The East Sea, a name deeply rooted in the lives of the Korean people, first appears in a historical document dating back to as early as 59 B.C. In the “History of the Three Kingdoms” (“Samguksagi”, 三國史記), the name East Sea was used in a chapter on King Dongmyeong, the founder of Goguryeo (one of the three ancient kingdoms in Korea). This proves that the name East Sea dates back more than 2,000 years, 1,700 years before the first appearance of the name Sea of Japan in “Mappamondo”, a publication by Italian missionary Matteo Ricci in 1602.

Historically, the East Sea has been an integral part of Korean history. It’s not up for a matter of debate.

It has a stronger claim over the Sea of Japan. A noteworthy example of the use of the name East Sea is the inscription on the stele of King Gwanggaeto of the Goguryeo Kingdom in 414 A.D. Since the territory of Goguryeo at that time extended as far as Manchuria in China, the name East Sea encompassed the waters not only east of the Korean Peninsula but east of the entire Eurasian continent as well. The stele was erected by King Jangsu in 414 A.D. in memory of the great work of his father, King Gwanggaeto of the Goguryeo Kingdom (37 B.C.-668 A.D.).

Nowadays, many of the world’s prominent cartographers and the media are beginning to recognize the validity of the name East Sea, and have moved away from the single use of Sea of Japan to the concurrent use of both names.

In some cases they even use only the name East Sea. In this view, the single use of Sea of Japan is problematic. Such trends suggest growing support and understanding for the name East Sea in the international community.

East Sea has stronger legitimacy than Sea of Japan

Japan is also starting to acknowledge that many prominent mapmaking companies are changing from the single use of Sea of Japan to the concurrent use of both names. Studies carried out by Japan and Korea respectively show that maps using both names concurrently are on the rise, increasing from 2.8 percent in 2000 to 10.8 percent (18.1 percent in the case of commercial maps) in 2005, followed by 23.8 percent in 2007 and then to 28.07 percent in 2009. These can be confirmed in such materials as booklets by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs called “Sea of Japan” (2002) and “A Historical Overview of the Name ‘Sea of Japan’” and surveys by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade of the Republic of Korea in 2007 and 2009.

According to Dr. David Munro, a British scholar of toponymy, geographical names are an expression of perceptions of a place, a means of communication about that place and a way of referencing. Since geographical names are a part of the lives of the people who use them, it is common practice to give the highest priority to the names used by local people when deciding on a name for international use.

More in favor of East Sea

Lying between Korea and Japan and extending north toward Russia, the area in question includes the territorial waters and exclusive economic zones (EEZs) of the countries encircling it. In other words, several countries share jurisdiction and sovereign rights over the sea. Furthermore, the body of water falls within the definition of a “semi-enclosed sea” as set out in the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea. A “semi-enclosed sea” is a gulf, basin or sea surrounded by two or more states and connected to another sea or the ocean by a narrow outlet or consisting entirely or primarily of the territorial seas and exclusive economic zones of the two or more coastal states.

When two or more countries share a geographical feature, its designation is generally standardized through consultations between the countries concerned. If efforts to standardize it fail, however, the names used by each of the countries are used concurrently. This general rule of international cartography is also confirmed in the IHO Technical Resolution A4.2.6. adopted in 1974 and the United Nations Resolution in the Standardization of Geographical Names III/20 adopted in 1977.

East Sea has stronger legitimacy than Sea of Japan

International Hydrographic Organization Technical Resolution A4.2.6 〈International Standardization of Geographical Names (1974)〉 states:

“It is recommended that when two or more countries share a given geographical feature (such as a bay, strait, channel or archipelago) under a different name form, they should endeavor to reach an agreement on fixing a single name for the feature concerned. If they have different official languages and cannot agree on a common name form, it is recommended that the name forms of each of the languages in question should be accepted for charts and publications unless technical reasons prevent this practice on small scale charts, e.g. English Channel/La Manche”.

Japan has continuously put forward a false argument that the name Sea of Japan has been authorized by the United Nations. However, it is the United Nations Secretariat, not the United Nations itself that uses Sea of Japan. This is merely a practice of convenience, which is not relevant to the opinions of the 193 member states of the United Nations. The U.N. Secretariat uses Sea of Japan in accordance with a practice to use the most widespread and generally recognized denomination in the absence of an internationally agreed standard. However, the U.N. Secretariat has clarified that its use of Sea of Japan does not constitute an official position of the United Nations but rather a practice of the Secretariat.

Furthermore, it emphasized that the practice should not be interpreted as advocating or endorsing any party’s position, and can in no way be invoked by any party in support of a particular position on the matter. Therefore, Japan’s argument is obviously a misleading interpretation of the U.N. Secretariat’s practice and is clearly false.

More than half of the IHO’s working group on the standardization of geographical names rejected a proposal to name the 978,000-square-kilometer area the Sea of Japan. The working group is made up of experts from 27 of the intergovernmental consultative organization’s 80 member countries.

The chairman of the IHO working group recently asked its 27 members, including the United States and China, to give their opinion on a compromise deal, which would name it the Sea of Japan and use the East Sea as an alternative name in the appendix.

In this regard, it was confirmed that slightly more than half of them expressed their disapproval for the proposal. China has indirectly expressed its displeasure with the suggestion, saying the “decision should be reached through a consensus”. France and Australia have reportedly expressed strong support for Korea’s demand to use both the East Sea and Sea of Japan to refer to the body of water.

The appellation Sea of Japan is a legacy of Tokyo’s brutal 35-year colonial rule over the Korean Peninsula, which ended in 1945 upon its defeat in World War II. Japan is believed to have begun to refer to the disputed area as the Sea of Japan in the late 18th century. It has been the dominant name for the body of water in the past century as it was commonly adopted by cartographers during the Japanese colonial rule of Korea. It is nonsensical to name a sea surrounded by four countries after only one of them.

Some experts have said that is common to name the body of water after the land on the left side of the sea, which in this case would be Korea, or the Sea of Korea, according to Philip Iglauer, an expert well versed in the appellation of oceans and seas. We live in a postcolonial world and we need postcolonial sensitivity.

Park Chang-seok is a research fellow of the Korea Institute of Public Administration (KIPA) under the Prime Minister’s Office. Park, a former managing editor of The Korea Times and a Kyung Hee University professor, is currently working on a book titled “Korean Maritime Sovereignty” planned to be published around the end of this year.

DON'T MISS

[Spoiler] Added episode 20 captures for the Korean drama “Yuna”s Street”

[Spoiler] Added episode 20 captures for the Korean drama “Yuna”s Street”

Added episode 20 captures for the korean drama "yuna"s street" (2014)directed by lim tae woowritten by kim woon kyeongnetwork : jtbcwith kim ok bin, lee hee joon, lee moon.
miss A”s Min is a sexy, blonde bombshell for “International bnt”

miss A”s Min is a sexy, blonde bombshell for “International bnt”

"when asked about ideal types, she said, "when i"m talking to somebody, i look at his eyes. Looking at his eyes, i think about that person alone. She said, "i want to do.
Kara to Meet Fans with New Face Next Month

Kara to Meet Fans with New Face Next Month

A new face will join just in time for kara"s new mini album, "day & night", which is set to be released in mid august. The newly formed quartet will meet fans as soon as.
Legend covers Yoonhan’s “Someone”

Legend covers Yoonhan’s “Someone”

Check out legend and their cover of “someone”:how do you like legend’s performance?source: jkspaceent. Legend gives fans a soulful rendition of yoonhan’s “someone.
[Album and MV Review] HyunA – “A Talk”

[Album and MV Review] HyunA – “A Talk”

Hyuna "a talk" album and mv reviewtrack list:01. With a brisk beat as well as insistent chattering of "ay ay ay ay ays" and "do it do it do its," it"s insanely catchy and.
4L reveals two additional 19+ dance version teasers

4L reveals two additional 19+ dance version teasers

Following their shocking debut teaser for upcoming track “move,” 4l has revealed additional dance version teasers for the entire group as well as fellow member jayoung!the.
HA:TFELT and 15& perform tear-jerking rendition of G-Dragon’s “That XXX” for Mnet’s “Singer Game”

HA:TFELT and 15& perform tear-jerking rendition of G-Dragon’s “That XXX” for Mnet’s “Singer Game”

Will, performing their own rendition of g dragon’s “that xxx. In this video clip, jyp entertainment’s ha:tfelt (wonder girls yenny) and duo girl group 15& battle against.
Radio DJs Cultwo Jokingly Pokes Fun At SISTAR Members For Not Having On Make Up

Radio DJs Cultwo Jokingly Pokes Fun At SISTAR Members For Not Having On Make Up

On july 29, sistar members dasom, bora, and hyorin appeared as guests on the sbs powerfm radio show “cultwo show” and the two djs poked fun at their bare faces. When.
T.O.P and Sohee Truly Look Like a Couple for Reebok Pictorial

T.O.P and Sohee Truly Look Like a Couple for Reebok Pictorial

84 million admissions, is once again centred around gambling and betrayal. P, the starring actors include shin sae kyung, kim yoon seok, honey lee, kwak do won, and many.
Singers Ye Eun and Baek Ah Yeon Take A Shiny New Selfie Together

Singers Ye Eun and Baek Ah Yeon Take A Shiny New Selfie Together

”ye eun is coming back to us after a much waited time with her first solo mini album “me?” on july 31. On that same day, she is showing her first solo debut performance.
Idol Group NU’EST Is Helping Out Children With Disabilities Through WEGENERATION Fundraising Campaign

Idol Group NU’EST Is Helping Out Children With Disabilities Through WEGENERATION Fundraising Campaign

This campaign will be conducted from july 30 to september 9 through the wegeneration homepage. ”nu’est will be picking one of the sponsors by drawing a lot and will.
“Reebok” release another paparazzi-style couple photo of models Sohee and T.O.P

“Reebok” release another paparazzi-style couple photo of models Sohee and T.O.P

P and sohee, making the paparazzi theme of their shoots even more obvious this time as the two are surrounded by a plethora of photo journalists sticking cameras into their.
Superstar K2 Park Boram’s astonishing transformation gains attention prior to her debut

Superstar K2 Park Boram’s astonishing transformation gains attention prior to her debut

Superstar k2 top8 contestant park boram will be making her debut soon, releasing a teaser image that has many talking regarding her obvious, but amazing transformation.
Actress Jang Shin Young Joins “The Spring Day of My Life”

Actress Jang Shin Young Joins “The Spring Day of My Life”

”meanwhile, “the spring day of my life” is a melodrama is about a woman who is terminally that receives a new heart through an organ transplant, and then she meets.
Kim Jong Kook’s Fans Gift “Running Man” Cast and Crew with 150 Servings of Samgyetang

Kim Jong Kook’s Fans Gift “Running Man” Cast and Crew with 150 Servings of Samgyetang

On july 29, fans of kim jong kook delivered the samgyetang meals to the gwangneung bonzai art park, where an episode of “running man” was being filmed. They especially.
MC Mong prepares for comeback

MC Mong prepares for comeback

Singer MC Mong is wrapping up recordings of his new songs to get ready for his comeback soon, according to local media reports yesterday.It is reported that the singer is.
Girl’s Day Wins This Week’s Show Champion Trophy With “Darling”

Girl’s Day Wins This Week’s Show Champion Trophy With “Darling”

Girl’s day took home the show champion trophy this week with “darling. ” congratulations!on july 30, the show tweeted a photo of the four ladies posing with their.
KARA’s Goo Hara Displays an Innocent Charm in “Day & Night” Individual Teaser

KARA’s Goo Hara Displays an Innocent Charm in “Day & Night” Individual Teaser

Goo hara is the last kara member to reveal individual teaser images for the group’s upcoming sixth mini album, “day & night. Goo hara wraps up the official “day”.
HA:TFELT (Wonder Girls’ Yeeun) Releases Solo Debut MV for “Ain’t Nobody”

HA:TFELT (Wonder Girls’ Yeeun) Releases Solo Debut MV for “Ain’t Nobody”

Wonder girls‘ yeeun makes her solo debut today under the stage name ha:tfelt. The music video for her track “ain‘t nobody” was released at midnight kst along with.
Kim Soo Yeon of Bubble Sisters to Get Married

Kim Soo Yeon of Bubble Sisters to Get Married

The wedding bells are ringing for kim soo yeon, a member of the vocal group bubble sisters. After participating in promotions for bubble sisters’ first album, kim soo.